Logistical
Considerations for Airborne GPS Photogrammetry in Remote
Areas
By
Robert M. Schweitzer
Airborne GPS is perhaps
the greatest technical advancement in mapping in the last
30 years. Never-the-less, use of this technology is not
without its own technical and logistical challenges,
particularly in remote areas of the world. AeroMap has
been involved with testing airborne GPS for the Remote
Sensing/GIS Center for the Cold Regions Research and
Engineering Laboratory, U.S. Army Engineers since early
1994. In addition, we have successfully completed
independent airborne GPS operations in urban and remote
areas of Alaska.
Our most recent project was
the control and acquisition of aerial photography for
creation of digital orthophotos at Cape Yakataga for the
University of Alaska, Office of Land Management. AeroMap
was contracted by Rick Rogers, senior forester, at the
university to produce 1"= 1000' digital orthophotos
with 50' contours for timber management and planning for a
125 square mile area. We were also to acquire 1"=
1320' color resource photography.
In analyzing the project,
we determined that the ortho imagery could be acquired as
black and white photography, flown at 20,000 feet above
mean terrain to minimize control requirements and reduce
the number of mapping models. The resource photography
could be acquired independently as uncontrolled imagery.
Cape Yakataga presented
logistical challenges for project photo control in that
the area is inaccessible by road, the terrain is difficult
and rugged, rising from sea level to 5000 feet with
glacier covered mountains. The project is 380 miles east
of Anchorage by air along the north coast of the Gulf of
Alaska. Access to Cape Yakataga was limited to a 3800 foot
gravel airstrip.
After laying out flight
lines for the 1:40,000 black and white photography, we
determined that traditional ground control would require
approximately 42 horizontal and vertical points. Layout
and planning for the control was made more difficult due
to glacial conditions in the inland high country.
As an alternative, AeroMap
recommended airborne GPS photogrammetry. Airborne GPS
relies upon a GPS-camera interface to determine exact
horizontal and vertical camera exposure stations during
the flight. Using this technology required only six ground
control stations plus one additional station for
occupation by a base GPS receiver during the photo
acquisition flight. We felt that six stations gave us
adequate ground registration plus a small buffer for
redundancy.
The university contracted
separately for survey of the six control stations and the
base receiver observation station. The surveyors used
differential GPS for the ground control based upon
existing National Geodetic Survey control stations near
Cape Yakataga. For purposes of resource mapping, we
decided that GPS vertical control adjusted to the Alaska
1994 Geoid Model would be adequate.
The surveyors opted for
post-marking rather than pre-marking the control. As they
reconnoitered the project with a helicopter to select
control stations, they laid photo panels over each
station. They then used the helicopter to hover above the
stations at 1000 feet to acquire several vertical
photographs of each panel, taken with one of AeroMap's 70
mm handheld cameras. The panel was then immediately
retrieved to eliminate the need to return at a later time.
Once the photography had
been acquired and processed, AeroMap used a control
transfer device to accurately mark the controlled stations
on the 1:40,000 scale photography from the 70 mm
photographs.
When the control work was
complete, the surveyors notified AeroMap so that we could
begin a weather watch for the project. In early June, a
high pressure system began moving through the interior of
Alaska, causing a dry northeasterly flow of air over Cape
Yakataga. Our flight crew and GPS operations manager
readied their operational plans. Early in the morning on
June 10, Andy Alexander departed Merrill field with the
GPS base receiver in his Cessna, bound for Cape Yakataga.
He was on sight by 10 a.m., where he recovered the base
station control point located near one end of the
airstrip. The photo ship departed Merrill at about 9:30,
allowing time enough for the sun to rise above 35 degrees
while enroute.
AeroMap uses
"On-the-fly" (OTF) GPS post processing
techniques which means the flight crew did not have to
land at Yakataga to initialize. They initialized while
airborne within about 15 miles of the base receiver. Andy
had set up his base station and was monitoring a VHF radio
so that he would know when to begin logging data. At the
appropriate signal, both the ground station and the
airborne receiver were activated.
The AeroMap crew flew the
required four parallel flight lines plus three
cross-flights over the project using standard 60 percent
endlap and 30 percent sidelap with a Zeiss TOP camera.
Though at least one cycle slip occurred during a turn, the
receivers reinitialized properly and the mission continued
successfully. When all lines had been flown to the
satisfaction of the flight crew, the GPS receivers were
shut down. Color resource photography was flown
independently.
Upon return to Anchorage,
the film was downloaded, processed, edited, and annotated.
The GPS data was also downloaded for post processing to
determine camera exposure stations. The exact camera
station positions were input into the aerotriangulation
process which was completed using specially modified
software for airborne GPS applications. The
aerotriangulation included 37 exposures from the four
primary flights, plus 28 cross flight exposures for a
total of 65 exposures in the simultaneous block
adjustment.
One of the six control
stations was located on a mountain top in a small opening
between snow fields. The point was difficult to read by
the plotter operator during the aerotriangulation. We
therefore decided to eliminate this station from the
control array rather than bias the entire project.
We are pleased with the
results of this project. Using five control stations, plus
six additional check points provided by the surveyors
throughout the project, AeroMap was able to obtain
residuals with root mean squares of 2.4 feet in X, 2.2
feet in Y, and 2.4 feet in Z. The collection of digital
terrain data for contour generation, digital elevation
modeling, and digital orthophoto production followed.
With the logistical
challenges of Cape Yakataga behind us, AeroMap is now
preparing for two linear projects. One is the 85-mile Tyee
Lake to Swan Lake Intertie for Alaska Energy Authority in
Southeast Alaska. The second is a 71-mile road project
from Savage River to Kantishna for National Park Service
in Denali National Park. Both projects will be completed
with airborne GPS relying upon OTF post processing. Due to
the lengths of these projects, multiple base stations will
be required along each route, using helicopter support for
deployment. The weather conditions, deployment of ground
stations, simultaneous activation and deactivation of
ground stations and airborne GPS receivers are all
critical to the success of these projects. As importantly,
in remote areas where control points and nearby airfields
are not available for initialization, on-the-fly GPS post
processing is essential.
As can be seen from the
above discussion, technical knowledge is extremely
important, but of equal importance is the logistical
experience, coordination, and planning that must go into a
remote project. A simple coordination oversight can be as
critical as a technical error. Either mistake may cause
loss of valuable time and resources. In remote locations,
there is no substitute for detailed planning.
About the Author:
Bob Schweitzer has been surveying and mapping
Alaska and other western states for over 30 years. He is
president of the American Society for Photogrammetry and
Remote Sensing, Alaska Region and a past president of
Alaska Society of Professional Land Surveyors. He is the
business development manager for AeroMap U.S.
BACK
|